This review originally appeared as a guest post on the excellent Christmas TV History blog run by our friend Joanna. We thank her for including us as guest bloggers and strongly encourage our readers to pay her site a visit! - RigbyMel and J.A. Morris
Premiered December 22, 1960.
The DuPont Show was an anthology series that ran from 1959 to 1961 and was hosted by actress June Allyson.
A man known only as "Benson" (Harpo Marx) is employed as a "mechanical man" (sort of a human wind-up toy) in a department store's Christmas window display.
|A man is shot dead outside the store window|
During one of his performances, a crowd gathers in front of the window to watch. One of the spectators is gunned down, two hit men escape. Benson is the only witness to this crime.
|Benson acts out the murder for the police.|
The killers want to take Benson out of the picture, so they stake out the department store.
Benson notices them on his way to work and a chase ensues. He hides at a warehouse until dark. Daniel, the night watchman (Ernest Truex) sees him and offers him shelter.
Daniel is a lonely widower and is glad to have company for the night. He loves to talk and calls the deaf Benson "the best listener" he's ever met.
The gunmen notice activity at the warehouse and pay a visit. Daniel gives them the runaround, but they rough him up, believing he will lead them to Benson
The gunmen notice activity at the warehouse and pay a visit. Daniel gives them the runaround, but they rough him up, believing he will lead them to Benson. Benson escapes and tries to get help in hopes that the police will come to rescue Daniel.
J.A Morris says:
I'm a huge fan of the Marx Brothers and "A Silent Panic" is something I've been aware of for years. But beyond a brief clip in a documentary, I'd never seen any footage until it was released on dvd last summer as part of The Marx Brothers TV Collection.
|Benson is questioned by the Lieutenant (Bert Freed).|
While it's certainly a "Christmas" story, the holiday makes its presence felt in subtler ways. The soundtrack features bits of "Hark The Herald Angels Sing", "Jingle Bells" and "Good Christian Men Rejoice." The interactions between Benson and the night watchman are very touching, there is lots of Christmas "good will" being shared between these men. You might say their Christmas present is finding a new friend.
If there's anything to criticize, the story is a bit slight. We never learn anything about the victim of the shooting, the hit men or why they killed him. At one point, the police ask Benson's boss if Benson is illiterate. The dialogue sort of dances around the answer. With the exception of Benson, none of the characters are given names. All the names listed in this review were taken from IMDB. But on the whole, it's a good story.
Benson runs through the snow and escapes to the warehouse.
In his memoir, Harpo Speaks, Marx says that whenever he had trouble remembering someone's name, he would call them "Benson." So I'm guessing his character's name was sort of an inside joke.
Some background on the rest of the cast and crew:
It should be noted that "A Silent Panic" was directed by Arthur Hiller. During his 50+ year career, Hiller directed many tv episodes and films, including Love Story and The Americanization Of Emily.
Daniel, the kindly nightwatchman is portrayed by Ernest Truex, who was a prolific actor in film and television. His career began in 1913, his credits include the screwball comedy classic His Girl Friday.
|Ernest Truex as Daniel|
Benson's employer Popper is played by John Banner. A few years after "A Silent Panic," Banner became famous for playing the bumbling Sgt Schultz on Hogan's Heroes.
|John Banner (left) as Popper.|
J.A. Morris' rating:
3 and a half candy canes.
"A Silent Panic" is quite an interesting holiday rarity. As J.A. Morris points out, the story itself is somewhat slight, but it's quite an endearing tale anyway, due to the acting. The script and the actors interpreting it do a lot more showing than telling.
We see the kindness of the night watchman as he shares his meal with the frightened Benson. Harpo Marx's skillful performance as Benson communicates the character's whimsy and worry without ever uttering a word. (Benson is sort of the ultimate in "show, don't tell" characterization!) The holiday message of being kind to one's fellow man comes through loud and clear without coming across as twee. I also quite enjoyed checking out the "holiday downtown of yesteryear" decorations and sets.
"A Silent Panic" is well worth checking out if you have the time and inclination this holiday season.
3 candy canes.